Posted inTHE LEDE

Why fertilizer exports cost the state more in gas than they earn

The temporary arrangement shifts more of the cost of securing gas onto producers while giving them freedom to earn export revenues

Every ton of urea made with imported LNG uses around USD 672-728 worth of gas before any other production costs, by our math, against the roughly USD 535 a ton FOB that Egyptian granular urea fetched for November contracts. Producing a ton takes around 24-26 mmBtu of gas, MEES East Med Editor Peter Stevenson tells EnterpriseAM, while the state pays roughly USD 28 per mmBtu for LNG, according to a government official quoted by Asharq Business.

Producers are now picking up more of that bill. Seven fertilizer companies agreed to pay a combined USD 175 mn upfront for gas (USD 25 mn each) under a 45-day arrangement starting yesterday, 16 November, that raises their gas price by 50% to USD 12.75 per mmBtu from USD 8.5, Asharq Business reports, citing government and company sources. In return, they can export all of their current output until early January and are temporarily exempt from supplying subsidized fertilizer to the Agriculture Ministry, but gas cuts of 20-40% remain in place.

BACKGROUND- The government cut gas to fertilizer and methanol plants by 20% at the start of the month before raising the cut to around 33% for Abu Qir Fertilizers, Mopco, and Egyptian Fertilizers Co. from 8 November, with Abu Qir shutting one of its three plants. It has also cut November LNG imports twice, first from 15 cargoes to nine and now to six.

The state is facing a difficult decision: “either import LNG at this high cost and pass it on to the industrial sector, or reduce imports and cut supplies to factories while calculating the least damage,” Hassan El Marakby, chairman and CEO of El Marakby Steel and vice-chairman of the Federation of Egyptian Industries’ metallurgical industries chamber, told us earlier this month.

Two different gas bills

Part of what makes the math messier than it looks is that factories and the state face different gas bills. The government draws on domestic production, Israeli pipeline imports, and LNG, each bought under different pricing arrangements, while producers pay contractual prices linked to international urea prices, with terms that differ from company to company, Stevenson says. If you price the gas at the JKM benchmark (which topped USD 34 per mmBtu at the end of October, as {we cited earlier this month), then the gas in a ton of urea would cost USD 816-884, by our math.

The gap isn’t a direct subsidy. “I wouldn’t necessarily characterize all fertilizer production as loss-making, or equate the difference between LNG prices and industrial tariffs with a direct subsidy of the same magnitude,” Stevenson tells us.

At lower gas prices, efficient plants could still earn Egypt more in export revenue than their gas costs, Blue Water Strategy Senior Advisor Cyril Widdershoven tells us. Whether those exports make economic sense also depends on each plant’s efficiency and the other production and loading costs that export revenues must cover.

On the other side of the ledger, cutting supply to heavy industry by around 350 mmcf / d saves the government about USD 321 mn a month in gas it would otherwise have to buy, a government official told Asharq. The net FX benefit depends on which LNG cargoes Egypt skips and how much fertilizer production it gives up, Widdershoven says. And since deferring cargoes postpones payments, the eventual saving depends on what Egypt pays when those shipments arrive, he adds.

Who gets cut first

Fertilizer plants are among the largest industrial gas consumers, and electricity supplies take priority, Stevenson says. They used 207.7 bn standard cubic feet (bscf) in FY 2024/25, about 39% of the gas Egyptian industry consumed, against 82.4 bscf, or roughly 15%, for iron and steel, according to Egyptian Natural Gas Holding Company data (pdf).

Beyond the grid, Widdershoven would allocate gas by foreign-currency return. Protecting electricity supplies makes sense if blackouts are the alternative, he says, but once the grid is secure, allocations should favor the plants that bring in the most net foreign currency per unit of gas. Prolonged blanket cuts risk sacrificing export earnings, with any resulting shortage of fertilizer at home potentially creating another import bill, he adds.

Producers could also stretch the gas they have, says Raed Al Soub, an independent adviser to the fertilizer and chemicals industries and former secretary-general of the Arab Fertilizer Association. He proposes temporarily shifting some orders from gas-hungry plants to more efficient factories or units with spare capacity, with the curtailed company paying an agreed fee and keeping its customers. Al Soub estimates each order would use around 16.7% less gas. The approach “ensures companies don’t shut down and deliver an economic benefit by sharing financial savings rather than sharing losses,” he tells us.

WHAT’S NEXT- Stevenson wouldn’t rule out cuts continuing through part of the winter, since restoring industrial supplies depends on LNG prices, continued Israeli pipeline supplies, and any improvement in domestic production. “Unless there is a meaningful improvement in those fundamentals, I think industrial gas rationing will remain part of the government’s toolkit,” he says.