Get EnterpriseAM daily

Available in your choice of English or Arabic

Egypt among most-improved on World Bank’s Doing Business report

1

What We're Tracking Today

What we’re tracking on 1 November 2018

We’re closing the week with more good news as Egypt ranked among the most-improved countries in the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business report. It’s the third reminder this week that smart government policy can make a difference, following news of the massive environmental benefits of the white taxi program and the near-elimination this fall of the annual “black cloud” over Cairo — both thanks to good policymaking. We have more in this morning’s Speed Round, below.

Two highlights outside the news well this morning: We have an exclusive opinion column from top execs and directors at three of the nation’s top mineral resources companies. And we’re very pleased to launch our new My Morning Routine column, which will run on Thursdays in place of On Your Way Out.

The first annual Middle East Conference on Business Angel Investmenttakes place today in El Gouna. The conference will bring together angel investors, venture capitalists and others to discuss the latest trends in fintech, clean tech, health technology and transportation technology. More here.

Egypt’s World Youth Forum 2018 will kick-off in Sharm El Sheikh this Saturday and run until Tuesday, 6 November.

Consumer protection watchdog enforces return policy on Sharm shops ahead forum: The Consumer Protection Agency (CPA) announced yesterday that it has enforced a return and replacement policy on all shops in Sharm El Sheikh before visitors start landing in the city for the forum, Al Shorouk reports. The agency also launched a campaign to “educate” tourists about their rights as consumers. The campaign sees flyers being distributed in airports, shops, hotels, and other public venues, as well as text messages, according to CPA boss Reda Abdel Moaty.

Markets closed October on a good note: “Global stocks ended a grim October on a brighter note, as corporate earnings on both sides of the Atlantic tempted investors back into a market beset by worries over rising interest rates, trade tensions and a slowing global economy,” the Financial Times writes. The WSJ zeroes in on US market performance. The EGX30 closed up 0.73% yesterday.

Credit Suisse’s Ahmed Badr snagged two bankers from BofA to help lead the Swiss lender’s new drive for market share in the Middle East, Bloomberg reports. “The Zurich-based bank appointed [Bank of America’s] Hamdy Hamoudi to lead equity sales in the region and Imran Dadabhoy to manage sales trading…[Credit Suisse] sales trader Karim Osman will relocate to Riyadh from London to manage equity sales trading.” Credit Suisse lured Badr back from Renaissance Capital last month to serve as managing director and head of equities for MENA as the bank looks to “rebuild its equity operations in Dubai after scaling back a few years ago amid a slowdown in trading.”

Reuters has an amazing series out on climate change headlined “Ocean Shock” that looks at the “climate crisis beneath the waves. Driven by warming waters, marine life is on the move — and life on land is forever changed.” The beautiful landing page for the 10-article series is here. Among the highlights of the package, which brings stories to life with stunning photography, video and data alike:

Egyptian journalist Hamdi Qandil passed away last night at the age of 82 after many years of battling disease, Ahram Gate reports.

In miscellany this morning:

US voters go the polls in midterm elections next week. We’re following the latest through the New York Times and Axios.

Inflation is now a thing in the United States. Not Egypt-in-2016/17-style inflation, but enough that the WSJ is declaring That Big Mac and Coke now comes with a side order of inflation.

Folding smartphones are coming. We’re gadget geeks. We’re also fairly sure we’ll be sitting out the first wave. (WSJ)

When your worlds collide: A 40-year-old guy in a small Norwegian town has become an internet and iTunes sensation re-recording pop songs as metal tracks. He somehow made the Wall Street Journal.

This publication is proudly sponsored by

2

Enterprise+: Last Night’s Talk Shows

Interview with IMF Egypt Mission Chief Subir Lall

** #5 An interview with IMF Egypt Mission Chief Subir Lall was the highlight of the night on the airwaves.

Egypt’s debt levels will remain safe as long as it holds the line on economic reform by remaining focused on phasing out subsidies and achieving a budget surplus, Lall told Yahdoth fi Masr’s Sherif Amer (watch, runtime: 1:12). Lall praised ongoing economic reform efforts during a discussion of Egypt’s latest staff-level agreement with the IMF for the fifth tranche of its USD 12 bn loan, on which we have chapter and verse on in this morning’s Speed Round, below (watch here, runtime: 3:06 and here, runtime: 2:16 ). He told Amer that reducing sovereign debt to 93% of GDP in FY2017-18 from 103% the year before was a “huge achievement” (watch, runtime: 1:36).

Job creation is Egypt’s current challenge and the private sector has a role to play here, Lall noted (watch, runtime: 1:59).

Lall was briefly dragged into potato-gate as Amer joined his peers in a modest freakout over the price of spuds. Lall suggested the spike in potato prices is not a sign the economic sky is falling, is likely temporary and added that the IMF has been in touch with the Agriculture Ministry to learn more about the issue (watch, runtime: 1:31).

Environmental issues were the order of the day on Masaa DMC, with Environment Minister Yasmin Fouad making an appearance on the show last night to discuss issues such as the pollution caused by burning rice straw (a widespread phenomenon across rural Egypt). Foad said that there have been fewer incidents of rice straw burning recently since the ministry began to take action (watch, runtime: 5:17). Sharqiya governor Mamdouh Ghorab also phoned into the show to talk about a thick cloud of black smoke that has formed over a village in Kafr El Sheikh from burning trash (watch, runtime: 10:21).

3

GUEST COLUMN

Top miners say forthcoming changes to mineral resources act are “extremely encouraging,” could unlock tidal wave of investment

** #2 GUEST COLUMN: Upcoming amendments to Mineral Resources Act are “extremely encouraging,” could unlock tidal wave of investment, say top mining companies in Egypt: Changes to the Mineral Resources Act now in the legislative pipeline to the will bring “immense benefits” to the mining industry, say senior execs and directors at three top players in Egypt’s burgeoning natural resources industry in an opinion column written exclusively for Enterprise. The signatories: Aton Resources President and CEO Mark Campbell, Thani Stratex Resources CEO David J. Hall and Resolute Egypt Director Ossama El Maghraby. The column:

The remarks about mining policy reform made last week by Minister of Petroleum and Mineral Wealth Tarek El Molla at an event hosted by the American Chamber of Commerce, were extremely encouraging to us in the industry.

The minister was very candid in stating that for too long, the fiscal terms used to commercially regulate mineral exploration and mining have been wrong, but that the government is going to fix this. He said they were going to create an investment-friendly environment to attract much needed capital into Egypt’s nascent mining sector so as to develop Egypt’s potentially vast mineral wealth in precious and base metals.

We in the mining sector were also extremely encouraged by the minister’s public recognition that oil & gas and mining have fundamentally different business models, and that their economics do not correlate in any way. The only relationship to be found between the two sectors is that they are extractive industries. To compare the two industries would be like comparing an airline to Uber just because they both get you from point A to point B.

The global mineral exploration and mining industry has its own set of industry standards and norms, and as such, mining companies go to countries where they are welcome. These are countries with well-developed terms and conditions designed to attract international capital. Investors make very high-risk and long-term investments and are inevitably drawn to countries whose governments firmly understand the sector and its needs, and that seek to engage into meaningful and long-term partnerships. These are businesses and though the geology may be great in country, if companies can’t ultimately bring a return to their stakeholders, they won’t come.

Egypt has taken some bold first steps to make investing in the sector more attractive. The government hired a globally recognized, resource consulting firm at the beginning of the year to identify the problems with its mining terms and conditions and to critically answer the questions: Why has only one new gold mine been developed in the last 90 years? Why are there only three international exploration and mining companies working here (despite having held multiple bid rounds)? As we understand it, the last time this consulting firm assisted a government (Ecuador) in unlocking its mineral wealth potential, which like Egypt had an oil and gas focused framework, it almost immediately attracted 400 companies to invest. This too could be Egypt.

Tap or click here to read the rest of the piece.

Do you have an idea for a Guest Column? Email patrick@enterprise.press.

4

Speed Round

Egypt jumps 8 spots in World Bank’s 2019 Ease of Doing Business report

** #1 More good news: Egypt is among the most-improved countries in the World Bank’s latest Ease of Doing Business report: Egypt jumped eight spots to rank 120th out of 190 countries in the World Bank Group’s 2019 Ease of Doing Business report (pdf). The country made it to the report’s list of top performers in 2017-18 thanks to the implementation of regulatory reforms that facilitated doing business in three or more of the 10 topics included in the report compared to last year. Here’s where we did well:

Starting a business: The process of starting a new business became easier over the past year with the introduction ofa “one-stop shop” for investors that doesn’t require a bank certificate, which helped reduce “regulatory complexity” in 2017-18. According to the report, it now takes an average of 11 days and 6.5 steps to start a business.

Making it easier to access credit: Egypt also worked on strengthening the legal rights of borrowers and lenders “by introducing the possibility of granting a non-possessory security right in a single category of movable assets without requiring a specific description of the collateral. Secured creditors are now given absolute priority over other claims, such as labor and tax, both outside and within bankruptcy proceedings,” the report said.

Egypt also stepped up protections for minority investors by expanding shareholders’ role in company management and “increasing corporate transparency.”

We can actually restructure with bankruptcy protection rather than go to jail: Under the subhed “resolving bankruptcy,” the World Bank notes that Egypt “introduced a new restructuring procedure, which included training programs on solvency law and allowed debtors to initiate the reorganization procedure and granted creditors greater participation in the proceedings.”

Paying taxes has also been made easier by improving the VAT refund process, extending it to refunds to manufacturers in case of a capital investment.

How did we fare in comparison to others? New Zealand remains at the top of the global ranking, followed by Singapore and Denmark. Somalia also retained its spot at the bottom of the chart, despite its score improving slightly y-o-y. The UAE was the highest ranked MENA country, climbing to the 11th spot from 21 last year. Morocco ranked 60 and Saudi Arabia ranked 92.

Other recent good news: Smart government policy helped virtually eliminate the “black cloud” that previously plagued the nation’s capital every fall and a World Bank report found the white cab taxi replacement program slashed Egypt’s carbon dioxide emissions by 310k tonnes in 2013-2017.

** #3 M&A WATCH- Sawiris’ Orascom Investment wants at least 25% of Sarwa Capital: Orascom Investment Holding (OIH)is looking to acquire a non-controlling stake of c. 216 mn shares in consumer and structured finance player Sarwa Capital at EGP 7.36 a share, the company said in a bourse statement (pdf). The company has filed for regulatory approval on the voluntary offer and has also expressed willingness to buy a smaller stake of 144-216 mn shares, but only at EGP 6.62 per share — a 10% discount to its price at the opening bell in its EGX debut last month, according to a statement from the FRA (pdf), which is studying OIH’s bid. OIH CEO Tamer El Mahdi told Bloomberg that “we’re looking to have something more than 25%,” adding that “we believe the price which is currently in the market is very attractive for OIH.”

The move is in line with OIH’s strategy to expand in the retail finance sector, which the firm sees growing as the economy continues to improve, El Mahdi also said. “The company fundamentals are very strong, and we have no concerns in terms of the stock’s performance since the IPO.”

The market reacts: Sarwa Capital’s shares jumped 10% after OIH’s announcement, closing at EGP 6.17 on Wednesday. The company’s shares had closed down more than 11% in their EGX debut amid the same Emerging Markets Zombie Apocalypse that shortly after prompted the government to delay its own share-sale plans. The EGX decided yesterday to raise the price limit on Sarwa’s shares to EGP 7.36 / share for a five-day window starting today. Reuters also has the story.

M&A WATCH- Banque Misr has sold its 2% stake in Saudi Arabia’s Samba Financial Group for USD 370 mn, Vice Chairman Akef El Maghraby told Reuters, without naming the buyer. El Maghraby told Sky News that the divestment came amid plans to sell stakes in entities in which the bank does not participate in management or in the decision-making process (watch, runtime 01:15). El Maghraby also said Banque Misr would not be selling its stake in Cairo-Amman Bank.

** #4 Egypt reaches staff-level agreement with IMF on fifth loan tranche: Egypt reached a staff-level agreement with the IMF yesterday on the fifth USD 2 bn tranche of its USD 12 bn extended fund facility after a delegation led by Egypt Mission Chief Subir Lall completed its fourth review of the government’s economic reform program. The delegation found that “the Egyptian economy continued to perform well, despite less favorable global conditions, supported by the authorities’ strong implementation of the reform program,” Lall said in a statement issued yesterday. The amount, which brings total payments under the program to USD 10 bn, will be disbursed after the IMF’s executive board signs off on the agreement. Finance Minister Mohamed Maait had previously said to expect that to happen in early 2019.

What’s going right: Driving the delegation’s decision are strong indicators of a promising outlook, including:

  • improvements in GDP growth levels;
  • a narrower current account deficit;
  • lower unemployment rates;
  • lower government debt levels relative to GDP.

The central bank’s tight monetary policy and flexible exchange rate regime are also expected to help “cushion [Egypt] against external shocks,” while the government’s fiscal policy is seen “keeping general government debt on a clearly declining path” to achieve a primary surplus for the first time in years. The delegation also took note of authorities’ commitment to energy subsidy reform and expanding social welfare coverage, as well as efforts to combat corruption and boost transparency.

Now Playing
Now Playing
00:00
00:00