Original movies and TV shows have taken a backseat to nostalgia. The entertainment industry has become a revolving door of reboots, remakes, and sequels — from resurrecting beloved classics such as Little Mermaid and Beauty and the Beast to reimagining cult favorites like Wicked or The Crow. This trend is more than a creative choice, it’s a strategic move to guarantee box office success. But why has Hollywood doubled down on recycling the familiar, and what does this say about the state of storytelling today?

(Tap or click the headline above to read this story with all of the links to external sources.)

Remakes and reboots are nothing new. The concept dates all the way back to the 1930s when Hollywood was in its prime. Back then, filmmakers used books or stage plays for inspiration to bring in audiences. Over time, this trend grew into a Hollywood tradition, especially during times when the industry needed a bit of a boost. Fast forward to today, and with streaming changing how we watch movies and COVID-19 reshaping theater habits, internal studio demand for modernizing these stories has only grown stronger.

At the core of this trend is nostalgia. Many of us have a deep emotional attachment to the stories and characters we grew up with, and these reboots give us a chance to reconnect with those memories. Take Disney’s live-action remakes of The Lion King and Aladdin, and the upcoming live-action Lilo & Stitch and Lion King prequel, Mufasa. They give adults the chance to relive the magic of their childhood while introducing it to a whole new generation in a fresh light. This psychological connection to familiar stories taps into a broader cultural need: to preserve the past while adapting it to fit the present.

…at least, it was. From a business perspective, reboots are a pretty safe bet for Hollywood, the 2019 live-action Beauty and the Beast grossed over USD 1.2 bn worldwide. Why? These films already come with an established fan base. Not only does that mean that the studios don’t have to shell out for marketing, they know that they can rely on strong opening weekends. And studios do what the box office numbers want.

But the real numbers favor streaming. Platforms like Netflix, Disney+, and Amazon Prime are constantly on the hunt for content that’ll grab viewers' attention, for better or for worse. Reboots fit this demand perfectly — they give you something familiar, but with updated visuals and storytelling. Those who are excited tune in to enjoy a fresh perspective and new visuals, and those who are cynical tune in to be able to critique it. At the end of the day, a view is a view, and all press is good press.

Another factor driving the popularity of reboots is the adaptation to today’s social and cultural changes. A lot of modern remakes are updated to reflect current values, especially when it comes to diversity and inclusion. Films like the 2023 The Little Mermaid and even the 1997 Cinderella reimagined iconic characters to appeal to a more diverse audience.

But there’s another force at play here: Last year’s WGA and SAG-AFTRA strikes — born out of long standing disputes over fair wages and residuals in the streaming era — caused a disruption in Hollywood, forcing studios to tighten their budgets and work around the shortage. With fewer original scripts available and pressure to keep releasing content, this may have pushed studios to resort to reboots/remakes to break even. Recycling old material became a creative shortcut that was meant to be temporary.

… But not everyone's on board with the reboot frenzy. Critics argue it’s ruining the drive for originality in Hollywood. Dr. Darren Fisher, a director and the head of the film department at Bond University, agrees that the industry’s economic incentives are clear, but he warns that " new blood " is needed to keep storytelling alive and thriving. Constantly recycling old stories could lead to audience fatigue, and eventually, interest in a remake will die down, especially when audiences lose faith in studios’ ability to be faithful to the source material.

The key to finding the right balance between staying true to the original material and making it feel fresh is another big challenge. Stray too far from what made the original great, and you risk alienating fans, who won’t show up to sequels. The 2016 Ghostbusters remake, which reimagined the iconic film with an all-female cast, is one example — and while it pandered to a growing need for female-led productions, its divergence from the content of the original films sparked a lot of controversy and mixed reviews.

In the end, the appeal of reboots and remakes is complicated — the formula for success needs a mix of audience interest, economic viability, and attention to cultural shifts. Nostalgia keeps reboots popular, and streaming platforms use them to attract subscribers globally, but a studio’s only output being recycled material indicates a creative bankruptcy that audiences don’t appreciate. For now, though, the financial incentives means the reboot craze will likely keep rolling on — until people stop funding it.

Tags: