Posted inThe Lede

5 big takeaways from the Nvidia scandal

The UAE’s chip deal, which expires in April, will be the biggest test of how far Washington goes

The abrupt downfall of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and a reinvigorated US emphasis on keeping advanced AI chips out of China don’t automatically spell trouble for the Gulf — but the warning signs are flashing red.

The first big question: Will AI security hawks in Congress and elsewhere stay narrowly focused on AI chips leaking to China via Southeast Asia? Or will they aim more broadly — including looking at the Gulf, where tech relationships with China have raised concerns in the past.

The second big question: How far will those hawks push things? Do they just want to impose new security measures on deals that grant broad access to top-shelf Nvidia AI chips to companies in the UAE and, to a lesser extent, Saudi Arabia? Or do they want to rein in AI chip exports more broadly?

The biggest test will be the UAE’s deal, which allows unlicensed purchases of cutting-edge Nvidia chips for national AI champion G42, its cloud division Core42, and several US companies operating in the Emirates. The deal for G42 and Core42 expires in April. It floats the idea of G42 and Core42 becoming US companies to retain that access, but doesn’t explain what either would have to do to be considered American.

If the US Commerce Department refuses to renew the agreement or places onerous restrictions on it, that will be a massive blow to the Gulf’s AI ambitions. It’s unlikely to end those ambitions, but it would make it far tougher for the Gulf AI industry to operate near the bleeding edge of the new technology — and may give Gulf nations incentives to look more seriously to China as a potential AI partner.

The Gulf looking eastward would also signal a substantial loss of political sway for the big AI firms — such as Microsoft and OpenAI — that have partnered on building Gulf infrastructure and mostly gotten what they want during the Trump administration.

“I don’t think anything over the last week guarantees that the Gulf is going to face significantly more US pressure,” Sam Winter-Levy (LinkedIn), a senior fellow in the Technology and International Affairs Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace think tank, tells EnterpriseAM. “But I do think there’s going to be more scrutiny in general of chip sales … and more scrutiny on the Gulf deals.”

Here are five big takeaways from the whirlwind week.

#1- The hawks are ascendant

The first two years of the second Trump administration were characterized by a laissez-faire approach to AI chip exports. The general idea was that it was better to get the world addicted to US AI than to hoard it — and that China would be less likely to catch up with America if Chinese companies were also hooked on US chips. (China officially only had access to older chip models, but top-line chips have consistently leaked through.)

But there’s nothing like the top advocate for your position getting duped by an alleged Chinese spy to change the narrative. Within the Trump administration, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has taken aim at Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, accusing his agency of erring in approving the sale of chips that ultimately made their way to China, mostly seemingly through front companies in Southeast Asia — and for refusing to blacklist Megaspeed, the Singaporean company at the center of the Huang scandal.

(Data point: Reuters identified USD 3 bn worth of Chinese projects built around Nvidia chips it shouldn’t have had access to)

Lutnick, whose department also approved chip sales to Saudi Arabia and the UAE, has been called to testify about the deals before the Senate Banking Committee next month. “This signals that the US government is moving away from its entirely laissez-faire approach to US AI exports,” Winter-Levy says. “It’s likely to scrutinize all of these deals much more carefully for alignment with US national security interests. … It will become harder to play the kind of swing-state, hedging role that a lot of Southeast Asian countries have been doing, and that the UAE has historically played.” (Winter-Levy has been a vocal critic of the UAE chip deal since it was announced.)

#2- Look to Congress

The Democrat-controlled Congress that will be sworn into office in January was always likely to take a close look at the Trump administration’s AI policy, but the incentives to do so got much stronger last week — both because of genuine national security concerns and the political value of making the Trump administration look opportunistic and naive.

Expected incoming Senate Banking Chair Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) wants to “put constraints on advanced AI chips going to China” and plans to “use her chairmanship to help shape rules for AI at home and abroad,” according to a statement her office shared with EnterpriseAM.

Warren’s office didn’t respond to a question about investigating the deal to expand UAE chip access, but Warren has previously slammed the agreement as corrupt and urged legislation that would have prevented it. Warren pointed to the reported USD 500 mn purchase of a 49% stake in World Liberty Financial, a Trump family cryptocurrency venture, by a vehicle thought to be controlled by a senior UAE official.

YES, BUT: Democrats have just two years until the 2028 presidential election and can’t pass any legislation into law before then without Trump’s signature. They’ll have to choose carefully where to focus — and Gulf chip deals may not make the cut.

“The US President has broad latitude on these matters, and it is unclear if political capital in the incoming Congress will be mainly spent on domestic matters, [such as] accountability of tech executives, or on reshaping export control policy,” Vincent Carchidi (LinkedIn), a defense industry analyst with Forecast International, tells EnterpriseAM. Carchidi added that he nevertheless thinks the UAE’s export status “is likely to be less certain next year.”

#3- The early indicators aren’t bad

Cracking down: The Trump administration imposed a new rule Monday requiring data centers that use US chips to serve companies in China, Russia, Iran, and Cuba to identify all their end-users. The rule also requires extra case-by-case licensing requirements for data centers in countries that “present a higher-than-normal risk of diversion,” namely Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, and Brazil. GCC countries are notably absent from the list.

IN CONTEXT- The rule landed three days before Trump meets Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the APEC summit on Thursday, where chip export controls are expected to be high on the agenda, Reuters reports.

Over the weekend, UAE officials also signed a new US-led declaration in San Francisco to protect the technology and infrastructure that AI supply chains depend on. The UAE is one of nine US allies to sign the accord, alongside Australia, India, Israel, Japan, South Korea, Qatar, Singapore and the UK, the State Department said.

Sound smart: The declaration sets up working groups on AI policy, adoption, supply chains, security hubs, and resilience. Other countries as well as the European Commission are set to sign next week. The declaration builds on Pax Silica, Washington’s coalition to secure supply chains for chips, AI models, and critical minerals, which the UAE joined in January as its ninth member.

MEANWHILE- The White House plans to name more than two dozen US firms — including Nvidia, Microsoft, OpenAI, Anthropic and Amazon — as AI “national champions” to help them beat Chinese rivals to overseas deals, the Wall Street Journal reports. The UAE and Saudi Arabia are exactly the kind of buyers the program targets — and keeping Nvidia on the list after the Huang scandal suggests the White House still wants to sell chips abroad.

Keeping perspective: “Counterparts globally may be expected to clear some new hurdles to ensure they are not diverting chips to China. However, G42 and Humain are not Megaspeed — they are government-backed entities with close relationships with many US firms that have already made efforts to demonstrate security controls for data centers and distance from Chinese firms,” Justin Alexander (LinkedIn), a Gulf business analyst and Director of Khalij Economics, tells EnterpriseAM.

#4- Remember there are countervailing forces

US tech companies have invested tens of bns of USD in building the Gulf’s AI infrastructure and don’t want to see its potential blunted. In other cases, such as the UAE Stargate facility, US firms are direct partners in the projects. And while those firms lost some political sway with the Democratic victory, they remain incredibly powerful.

The US economy is also highly dependent on both the building of AI capacity and the broader tech sector. Democrats are unlikely to do anything that risks saddling a potential 2028 Democratic president with a recession.

YES, BUT: We don’t know what we don’t know. If investigations into Huang’s relationship with the alleged spy (confusingly named Alice Huang) reveal that significant secrets leaked to China — or if it turns out the leakage of Nvidia chips to China was far greater than known — there could be more political appetite for broadly rethinking US export controls.

#5- The UAE may be in a stronger position

It’s not clear how many top-line Nvidia chips the UAE and Saudi Arabia have purchased so far, but G42 and Core42’s license-free access to those chips suggests the UAE likely has a substantial number on hand — putting the nation in a stronger position if the US grip on those chips tightens in the future.

“It’s hard to take back what is already there,” William Reinsch (LinkedIn), a former US Commerce Department official who was in charge of export control policy during the Clinton administration, tells EnterpriseAM.

More chips also means more time to wait for tempers to cool in Washington. “The debate between China hawks who want to tighten export controls and the business community, which wants a more nuanced approach, has been going on for at least 35 years,” Reinsch says. “At the moment, thanks to Huang and Nvidia, the hawks appear to have the advantage, but the debate is never going away, and the pendulum usually swings back the other way, though it may take years for that to happen.”